Repo Critique Synthesis Prompt

prompts/repo-critique-synthesis-prompt.md · 2161 B · source sha256 e7f9a6657fff

GitHub // main raw .md

Use this prompt to fold another independent fresh-context critique into the critique just produced above and produce an advisory plan.

Following or attached is another independent critique of <project> produced by a separate fresh-context thread.

  1. Consider and fold it into your above critique.
  2. Make an advisory plan to address the issues that survive synthesis.

Carry through any second-lens findings. If either critique surfaced relationship-scope / language-governance observations — terms that mis-scope a relationship or silently flatten a distinction — fold them into the synthesis at that altitude; do not drop them as wording nits. Preserve each with its decision owner (executor wording fix · advisor-review issue · ASK source-of-intent call).

Delivery

Open with a By: line stating who produced this synthesis (e.g. By: claude-code), in both the reply and the saved file — the <source> token is required so a Claude synthesis and an advisor synthesis can be told apart. This <source> token is a critique-cycle disambiguator, not a default model/source suffix for handoffs or other artifact classes.

Deliver the synthesis (the folded critique + advisory plan) in two forms:

  1. In reply — the full synthesis inline in your response.
  2. As a saved Markdown artifact — the same synthesis as a standalone .md file:
    • If you can write files (a file-capable executor, e.g. Claude Code): save it into the repo's operator-side scratch, <repo>-EXTERNAL/scratch/.
    • If you cannot save directly (a save-blocked advisor): emit it as a downloadable .md file, same filename, for the operator to place there.

Name the file per the protocol below (consistent with ASK's file-naming conventions in the context-architecture ADR every surface carries in context):

YYYY-MM-DD_<repo>_repo-critique-synthesis-<source>[-rN].md

  • <source> — claude-code / advisor-gpt / advisor-claude.
  • example: 2026-06-07_urban-observatory_repo-critique-synthesis-advisor-gpt.md

Other independent critique to fold in

Paste or attach the other critique below.